---
product_id: 8356766
title: "Perspectives on Satipatthana"
brand: "bhikkhu analayo"
price: "NT$1642"
currency: TWD
in_stock: true
reviews_count: 13
url: https://www.desertcart.tw/products/8356766-perspectives-on-satipatthana
store_origin: TW
region: Taiwan
---

# Perspectives on Satipatthana

**Brand:** bhikkhu analayo
**Price:** NT$1642
**Availability:** ✅ In Stock

## Quick Answers

- **What is this?** Perspectives on Satipatthana by bhikkhu analayo
- **How much does it cost?** NT$1642 with free shipping
- **Is it available?** Yes, in stock and ready to ship
- **Where can I buy it?** [www.desertcart.tw](https://www.desertcart.tw/products/8356766-perspectives-on-satipatthana)

## Best For

- bhikkhu analayo enthusiasts

## Why This Product

- Trusted bhikkhu analayo brand quality
- Free international shipping included
- Worldwide delivery with tracking
- 15-day hassle-free returns

## Description

Perspectives on Satipatthana

## Images

![Perspectives on Satipatthana - Image 1](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/515cF0Bi6SL.jpg)
![Perspectives on Satipatthana - Image 2](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41jNXh+1KEL.jpg)
![Perspectives on Satipatthana - Image 3](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/31rQJaMqw9L.jpg)

## Customer Reviews

### ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 







  
  
    This is a wonderful book, but ...
  

*by E***E on Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on May 28, 2017*

This book is about Buddhist meditation, particularly the (four) Foundations of Mindfulness. It is a good book, well written, interesting, and informative. It does require some prior knowledge of Buddhist principles with particular reference to meditation methods. So, it  might be helpful to read the author's previous work about the subject, "Satipatthana: the Path to Direct Realization", as an aid to understanding.Analayo is a scholar-monk and a well recognized expert about the differences between the canonical books from the Theravada Buddhist tradition (Nikayas), originally recorded in Pali, and parellel books (Agamas) from other ancient mainstream (i.e., non-Mahayana) schools that existed in northern India. Those have been lost in their original languages and are mostly available only in Chinese or Tibetan. Analayo and his academic colleagues work to reconcile those teachings from north Indian schools with each other and with the south Indian Pali version that is well known in the west.  This book discusses three parellel versions of a single discourse, the Satipatthana Sutta, two in Chinese and one in Pali.Classical Buddhism split due to disagreements about certain issues at the second Buddhist council (ca 386 BCE) about 100 years after the Buddha died. And the schisms continued. Sometime during the third century BCE (ca 247) a canon from one such lineage (Sthavira, Vibhajjavādin, Theravadin) was transported south to Sri Lanka where it was written down in the Pali language about 100 BCE.  The schisms continued between the second Council and the turn of the millennium. Schools were formed;  some vanished. Some 18 to 20 traditional schools remained - and the Mahayana Buddhism had begun to emerge.  Needles to say, that history is highly approximate. The point is that there was much opportunity for discussion, debate, and reformulation of doctrine and beliefs among the different schools during those centuries.Unfortunately the original language Cannons from the northern schools were lost during the Arab and Turkish invasions of India that began in the 8th century CE and continued in waves of increasing ferocity during the 10th to 13th centuries. Oral traditions, monasteries, temples, and even universities were destroyed in the pillage. Documents were burned and knowledgeable people killed. Those conquests led to the Delhi Sultanate that ruled much of India for the next 300 years (1206 - 1526). Thus, Buddhism was forced out of its homeland in favor of Islam.Some documents and traditions, however, had migrated with pilgrims to China and Tibet before the full effect of the invasions was realized. They were translated into local languages. It is those documents Professor Doctor Analayo and his academic colleagues seek to translate, organize, interpret and share with us today. This book discusses the parallel versions of a single discourse (the Satipatthana Sutta) of which there are two Chinese versions from different schools and one Pali version from the Theravada tradition. He does digress to other Suttas to make specific points.Full text translations of the three parallels are provided. Quotations in the body of the book are taken mostly from the Chinese versions. Useful figures are provided to illustrate important points. Bhikkhu Analayo offers informed interpretation, comment and opinion about the parallels particularly noting differences and similarities. I must say I was struck by how similar they are despite some interesting differences. And some of those differences might prove illuminating to the interested reader or curious practitioner.For example, the author discusses a discourse that mentions three Satipatthanas instead of the usual four. While the name is the same, "Satipatthana", the subject is much different. Here, the Buddha is teaching disciples about the Dhamma. The circumstances are three-fold:  #1) the students are disrespectful, disregarded instructions, and don't understand, #2) these students are quite the opposite. They are respectful, diligent and understand the Dhamma, #3) this group is a 50-50% mix. According to the Chinese versions the Buddha is totally equanimous no matter the circumstance - neither sorrowful or happy - the result of the teaching made no difference.The Pali version, however, makes it clear that these three foundations are meant to evaluate whether a teacher is fit to instruct groups of students (MN 137: 21). In situation #1 above, the Buddha is "not satisfied" (with the outcome). He is, after all, teaching "out of compassion" for his disciples. He is not satisfied, yet "he dwells unmoved, mindful, and fully aware". In other words, he is not satisfied with the result but is emotionally unmoved - i.e., he is equanimous. In #2, the Buddha is satisfied. Yet he nonetheless "dwells unmoved, mindful, and fully aware" - equanimous. In #3, the mixed group, he is neither satisfied nor dissatisfied, "free from both satisfaction and dissatisfaction" yet "he dwells in equanimity, mindful and fully aware". (MN 137:21-24)The author focuses on the Buddha's dissatisfaction in the Pali version. He concludes that it must have suffered a "transmission error" because the vote is 2 to one, Chinese vs. Pali, and the Buddha is said to be always equanimous. I respectfully submit that blaming the difference on an error may have missed a subtle but important point.I cannot imagine, for example, that a teacher, instructing out of compassion for the welfare of his students, would not be dissatisfied if those students failed to understand his important message. Not caring about the result, indifferent to it, is not an attitude of a good teacher - or for that matter anyone doing a job, particularly for one who serves others. So the Buddha is satisfied or dissatisfied, but either case he remains "unmoved". Dissatisfaction does not imply condemnation. Similarly, he is satisfied but also remains unmoved because satisfaction does not mean praise.The Pali version, but not the Chinese, seems to capture the difference between equanimity and its near enemy - indifference. Some see little distinction between the two. But they are actually quite different  just as compassion and pity are quite different, similarly loving kindness and sensual love. See Visuddhimagga, IX 98-101 ("The Near and Far Enemies"), particularly section #101. The Chinese versions seem to miss that subtle but important point. Perhaps the distinction was added to the Pali version later.Or perhaps it was not recognized by some north Indian traditions or was lost in translation to Chinese. It matters little, because there are subtle differences between a wholesome attribute like compassion and its less wholesome near enemy, pity. The difference is not noticed by some because they share a common attribute - e.g., observing an unpleasant event.  Similarly loving kindness and sensual love that can be easily confused.  Equanimity and indifference apply to attributes like faults and virtues;indifference ignores them completely. However, wholesome (favorable) and unwholesome (unfavorable) events can be recognized as such without emotional involvement or judgment. Thus, assuming that inconsistencies are simply due to errors of some sort, "transmission errors", may lead to lost interpretive opportunities.Similarly, the author opines that the Five Hindrances should be substituted for the four Jhanas (or Adsorptions) in the list of dhammas from one of the Chinese parallels. The dhammas (otherwise translated as mind objects, processes, or principles) is the last and most subtle of the 4 Satipatthanas. The Adsorptions, it is said, appear instead of the Hindrances due to a "textural error".Figure 9.1 (page 164) summarizes the dhamma lists among the three parallels (also in Figure 1.1). The Pali version lists 5; the Chinese versions list 3 and 2 respectively. All name the Enlightenment Factors. The 2-item Chinese parallel lists the Adsorptions; the other Chinese version names the Hindrances and Sense Spheres. The Pali parellel names the Hindrances, Sense Spheres and 2 others (the Aggregates & Four Noble Truths).  Substituting the Hindrances for the Adsorptions, based on a presumed error, allows the author to claim that Enlighten Factors and Hindrances are consistent among the dhammas and therefore presumably the most important.But perhaps the Mahasanghika school, the presumed source of the 2-item parellel (see page 3) really did conclude that the Adsorptions were important dhammas - in contradistinction to the other two traditions. There was much discussion of Buddhist opinion and many schisms of Buddhist schools between the Second Buddhist council and the turn of the millennium. There was sufficient disagreement during the period, for example, that the Mahayana form of Buddhism began to emerge.Several observations suggest that that the difference may not be an accident. First the Mahasanghika Chinese parellel starts by mentioning a "one-going path" that is "required for purification of beings and  removing worry and sorrow" as well as gaining wisdom. "One-going" is defined as "unification of the mind". The path is the Noble Eightfold Path. The prologue claims, "That is, the 5 Hindrances should be eliminated and the 4 Satipatthanas attended to."Thus, "unification of the mind" is required for the whole Path and the five Hindrances should be eliminated (suspended by the unified mind) before proceeding to the 4 Satipatthanas. It is difficult to imagine how this ordered sequence could be the result of an error. The Adsorptions simply could not have been substituted for the Hindrance  because the suspension of latter appears to be a prerequisite for Satipatthana meditation. That is to say, one needs unified mind - not a scattered mind.Second, Professor Analayo says that the Mahavedalla Sutta (MN 43) stipulates that unification of the mind is required for developing the Adsorptions and that such a mind is incapable of understanding variety and change. MN 43, however, also stipulates that the 5 Hindrances are abandoned as part of developing the 1st Jhana (adsorption) process (MN 43:20). Thus, it is entirely reasonable to assume that the Mahasanghika monks thought that Adsorptions were indeed dhammas, that unification of the mind is required early on and that eliminating (suspending) the Hindrances to meditation is helpful (required) for effective Satipatthana meditation.Third, the Jhanas are associated with evolving states of consciousness like applied thought, rapture, happiness and so forth. They are well described in the discourses and are the hallmark of deepening concentration - one pointedness. It is difficult to understand how they could be defined so clearly unless meditating monks were able to mindfully note those changing states of consciousness, remember them, and write them down. Indeed, the characteristics of each Adsorption in the Mahasanghika parellel are considered a foundation of mindfulness (i.e., a Satipatthana, see translation, page 294).Fourth, planes of consciousness during an existence are said to influence the destination realms for rebirth in a next existence; attainment of the Jhanas is associated with rebirth in more favorable realms (Bodhi: Middle Length Discourses of the Buddha, p 47; Walshe: Long Discourses, pp 37-42; Bodhi: Abhidhammattha Sangaha, Table 5.1). It is possible or even likely that the Mahasanghika monks were familiar with that concept so emphasized the Adsorptions in their meditation practice.Finally, it is equally interesting that the different sources name different numbers of dhammas. That observation may actually be more interesting than analysis of why one source names the Adsorptions while the others do not.It is theoretically true that regressing comparable statements from a number of texts can lead to an idea about some common historical progenitor. Such a practice used with the Gospels of the Christian Bible lead to re-construction of the lost Q-Gospel. But assuming that a text should have read otherwise actually frustrates the process. Indeed, it might even lead investigators to confirm their own preconceptions. Perhaps ancient monks in those evolving Buddhist schools simply had different views about the some of the Buddha's teaching.So, that is the reason for the four stars. For me, personally, the book was well worth at least 6 stars. And the author deserves much credit for his extensive efforts to make thismaterial available to the rest of us.

### ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 







  
  
    Please add this to your list of great works on Buddhism
  

*by H***T on Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on March 5, 2017*

I have not yet read this book as a whole, and can only attest to skimming through and pausing to read a few paragraphs here and there in each chapter to decide if it is in my reading and study list. It is a book for faith, for religious knowledge and practice. If you want to understand this path more then you have the correct book here. I look forward to reading it cover to cover, slowly, deliberately and with a notebook by my side. I have been studying Buddhism all my life and sometimes it strikes me as such a complex faith that I do not know if I will ever be fulfilled. I always want to learn more, to read the many paths and perspectives that I may have missed, and yes it is easy to miss what is right in front of you at times. This is how I feel about this book. It has always been there, it was me late to the page, not the page late to me.

### ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 







  
  
    Love this author - Analayo
  

*by L***R on Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on April 10, 2014*

I started reading this book.  I read the first one by him "Satipatthana: The Direct Path to Realization" and appreciated the user friendly content.  This book is on a higher plane and I have started but it will take me a while to go through it.His previous book could be read in conjunction of CD's on the same subject entitled "Abiding in Mindfulness" by Joseph Goldstein.  I think that is where you need to start and then proceed to this book....UNLESS, you are an advanced Buddhist and you are ready to dig deeper into Satipatthana: The Four Foundations of Mindfulness.I will keep you posted as I progress in reading this book.  But I warn you, it will be slow. :)

---

## Why Shop on Desertcart?

- 🛒 **Trusted by 1.3+ Million Shoppers** — Serving international shoppers since 2016
- 🌍 **Shop Globally** — Access 737+ million products across 21 categories
- 💰 **No Hidden Fees** — All customs, duties, and taxes included in the price
- 🔄 **15-Day Free Returns** — Hassle-free returns (30 days for PRO members)
- 🔒 **Secure Payments** — Trusted payment options with buyer protection
- ⭐ **TrustPilot Rated 4.5/5** — Based on 8,000+ happy customer reviews

**Shop now:** [https://www.desertcart.tw/products/8356766-perspectives-on-satipatthana](https://www.desertcart.tw/products/8356766-perspectives-on-satipatthana)

---

*Product available on Desertcart Taiwan*
*Store origin: TW*
*Last updated: 2026-02-09*