One Day in December: Reese's Book Club: A Novel Kindle Edition

I’ve read this book twice years apart and loved it just as much the second time around. I cried both times!

This was a good book but it got on my nerves a bit. I felt bad for all the people involved. I know it would be a tough situation and I really don’t know how I would react but I would hope it wouldn’t be like they did. It was a good story but I didn’t love it as much as I thought I would.

OK. OK. I admit...I actually liked this book. I liked it a lot.Before I start, here's a warning...SPOILERS GALORE AHEAD!A classic tale of love at first sight that took years, actual years, to resolve. We've seen this story, we've read about it, whether in real life, or in books, or in movies. I was very wary about getting this book or reading it, I didn't want the frustration of wanting two characters to end up together for the WHOLE. FREAKING. BOOK.But...this wasn't like that. I mean, sure, there was frustration. But it's not that bad. For many reasons.1. The 'love at first sight' part was kind of silly, and although Laurie spends a good while searching for this random stranger at the bus stop, he remains just that - a stranger. So when she does actually get introduced to him eventually, as her best friend's boyfriend no less, it's frustrating, but not THAT frustrating, because hey! You don't actually know this guy, OK? And to Laurie and Jack's benefit, they both realize that as well, and deal with it.2. You actually can't help but love Sarah (the best friend). And you want what's best for her. And you really like her relationship with Jack, and so you can't be that frustrated, because they work.3. Jack and Laurie's evolving friendship is endearing, and although you can tell there are underlying romantic connotations there, it's still a really sweet friendship.That being said, ten years is a really long time for someone to be in love with someone else. Ten years is a really long time and people change. I really enjoyed the whole first section of the book, when Sarah and Laurie were flatmates, and all the ups and downs and evolution of friendships and relationships.The second section, when Laurie leaves England was also very interesting, and I really liked seeing Laurie separated from Sarah and Jack. Finding herself, relying on herself, and really discovering her own identity separate from these 2 individuals who have shaped her life and character for so long.The third section, when she's back, was rocky, but needed I guess. Seeing the changes in Sarah and Jack, the shift in their relationship, seeing Laurie happy in her own relationship, it was all very realistic.Then came Jack's accident, and that part was...dramatic? I don't know, I wasn't a huge fan. Did Jack need more reason to be a jerk? He was already acting like one prior to his accident. It also seemed to go on for a while, and I kind of just wanted to get on with the story.Then there was Laurie's wedding...and the big revelation the night before when Sarah discovers, well, pretty much everything. Another super dramatic event that wasn't necessary. Personally, I didn't see any reason for Sarah to ever find out about Jack being the bus boy. Also, there was absolutely no reason for her to ever find out about the kiss that happened a hundred years ago. And also, she had no right to get THAT upset about all of it because she wasn't with Jack anymore, and at that point, hadn't been with him for a while! So to miss your best friend's wedding, the best friend who just gave you her dead sister's bracelet, is a HORRIBLE thing to do and is inexcusable.The ending, with the whole radio thing, and the letter, and all that cute stuff. I mean, God, FINALLY. I really, truly enjoyed this story. Not because it was the best story, and not because it was out of this world fantastic and different, but I think the main reason I really enjoyed this story is because I genuinely liked all the characters in this book. Every single one of them. So good on you Josie!

The review are excellent for the right age group - maybe 18 to 35 but for someone older than 65 - it is very contrite! I guess if I read what the book was about I should have known !

The first chapter immediately grabbed me - love at first sight was truly described within the first few pages. The next couple of chapters were a bit slower as to establish relationships and timelines, but once I was about 40% through I was HOOKED!The main characters are so loveable and relatable - there is truly no antagonist in this story. Each character was worth rooting for and there were a few instances and chapters that were so hard to get through after growing so attached to each of them.I found this story unique in the author's ability to make time pass without feeling like too much of a gap. Each chapter seemed to flow into one another, even if a large amount of time passed. She did an amazing job at telling the story with the most important pieces, but without anything being rushed.I would definitely recommend this read, not only for the winter as the setting frequently changes!

Loved this book so much. Thinking it was a slow start then it took off with heart felt emotions. Brought back memories of my younger years.

"One Day in December" by Josie Silver is an absolute gem of a book that I couldn't put down. From the very first page, I was captivated by the beautiful tale of love, fate, and friendship. The characters are so relatable that I felt like I was in the story myself.The story is both heartwarming and heart-wrenching, making it impossible not to get invested with all sorts of emotions. Silver's writing is unique, details vivid scenes that put you right in the moment with the characters.I've recommended this book to multiple friends, and they all ended up purchasing it and loving it just as much as I did. It's a testament to the universal appeal of this enchanting story. Whether you're a hopeless romantic or just looking for a beautifully written novel, "One Day in December" is a must-read. It will leave you with a warm, fuzzy feeling and a renewed belief in the magic of love and fate.

I wouldn't say this is a Christmas book but more of a good romance book. I don't love the whole best friends boyfriend but I hate to also admit how realistic it is. This is why you pick friends who don't have the same taste as you.It was very easy to get lost in the story. I felt like I was kicking back wine with the girls or at the fancy house parties. It was also paced very well. This book needs more loveSPOILERSFew spoiling things Oscar was definitely cheating and so was sarah. You can write it how you want but that's what was happening even if our main characters never knew.Also missing your best friends wedding then leaving her while her husband is just going away for half the week is not cool. And everyone but the core group definitely knew about Jack an Lu.